x
Close
Inside Africa

The Hurdles And The Triumphs

The Hurdles And The Triumphs
  • PublishedJuly 26, 2012

This month, the African Union (AU) celebrates 10 years since being founded as a successor to the largely misunderstood Organisation of African Unity (OAU). The anniversary comes at
a very interesting time for Africa, a continent now glowing with optimism following its best decade (2001-2011) in terms of economic growth. As part of the celebrations, we dedicate this month’s
Special Collector’s Edition to the AU’s evolution as well as taking stock of its successes, challenges, failures, and future prospects. Our deputy editor, Regina Jane Jere, kicks off our coverage with an overview of how the AU is positioned in the Africa of today.

THE WORLD IS SINGING A DIFFERENT TUNE ABOUT Africa, and refrains such as “Africa is awakening”, “Africa rising”, “the hopeful continent” and many more encomiums are filling the air, hailing an Africa once seen as “the hopeless continent” (to quote The Economist of 13-19 May 2000). And indeed as the continent’s foremost body, the African Union (AU) turns 10 years old, this is a good time to reflect and appraise how far Africa has come and has yet to go.

As expected, the question many are asking is: “What has the AU achieved in the past decade?” There are different aspects to this question as our pages will reveal. However, although the AU and Africa at large may seem to have come a long way, it should be emphasised that the AU is still very much in its infancy and has yet to cut its teeth. As such, sensational and cynical headlines such as “African Union: Short of cash, and teeth” by (guess who?) The Economist (January 2011) simply hold no water – the jury is still out.

However, one of the AU’s fundamental aims at its formation on 9 July 2002, as propounded by the then South African president, Thabo Mbeki, was to ensure that “Africans own and control Africa from Cape to Cairo”. As Mbeki put it before the joyful crowd at Durban’s ABSA Stadium, where the AU was officially launched 10 years ago: “Imperialism and colonialism had sought to own and control Africa permanently, from Cape to Cairo… and the African pride [the AU] will ensure that Africans own and control Africa permanently from Cape to Cairo.”

Fast-forward to 2012. “Ownership”, “control”, and “pride” are still some of the hot topics that excite debate about Africa and the existence of the African Union. Later on in this special report, our associate editor, Cameron Doudu, gives a broader view on the formation of the AU.

He tells how the AU is a “child” born out of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) – the post-independence organ whose main job was the political liberation of the African continent from colonial rule.
With the emancipation of South Africa from apartheid oppression in 1994, the OAU’s job was effectively done. Although widely criticised as having been ineffectual, the OAU did give Africans physical “ownership” and “control” of their countries (from colonial domination) and thus brought real “pride” to the then abused “natives” of Africa.

Hence from the very outset, at the formation of the AU, economic freedom and development of the continent and its people were put high on the AU’s priority list. As President Mbeki said at the time: “The African Union will be an economic union, or it will be nothing … there can be no meaningful African Union that is based on unity in poverty.”

To strengthen this premise, the 37th OAU Assembly, held in the Zambian capital Lusaka, not only adopted the roadmap for the establishment of the AU, but also its socio-economic development programme, the New African Initiative, which was later renamed the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (Nepad).

“To a degree, we can say that this signified the reinvigoration of the agenda of the African national democratic revolution,” Mbeki recounts in an article titled “Celebrating the 10th Anniversary of the African Union”. “Thus we saw, coming back to the centre stage, fundamental prescriptions of that revolution, such as: Africa’s duty to exercise her right to self-determination, free from foreign interference and neo-colonial dependence; our obligation to accelerate the process towards the political and economic integration and unity of Africa; and the right of the people of Africa to control their natural and other resources and utilise these to achieve their development, for the eradication of poverty and underdevelopment; and repudiate the theft of national wealth by a corrupt and predatory elite.”

Mbeki continues: “We saw [in the AU and Nepad] the transformation and modernisation of the African economies to end their status as producers and exporters of raw materials, thus also to end the unequal and exploitative economic relations between ourselves and the North, and [the desire] for Africa to assume her rightful place within the global governance, to end her marginalisation, as well as her grossly unequal access to the claimed benefits of the process of globalisation.”

Therefore, in taking stock of the AU’s tenth year of existence and how it sits in the Africa of today, economic clout, economic freedom, and economic development are deep-set. But how, and where, has the AU travelled during these 10 “short” years? How many of its original aims and objectives have actually been achieved?

The critics

Understandably, the AU has no shortage of detractors and critics. Even its supporters, like Mbeki, are equally critical of what has happened in the past decade. “As we celebrate the first decade of the AU and Nepad and prepare to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the OAU next year,” Mbeki says, “we must answer some questions honestly: What progress have we made towards the achievement of the objectives set by the OAU, AU and Nepad? What shall we do in this regard?”

The former South African president admits that “much still remains to be done” to realise the AU’s objectives. He highlights three areas where the AU has clearly faltered:

(1) “Africa’s snail’s pace towards political and economic integration, in terms of implementing the agreed bottom-up, rather than an adventurist top-down strategy, with regards to an accelerated advance to African unity.

(2) “The shameful African disunity and indecisiveness which resulted in the debacles in Côte d’Ivoire and Libya, which put in serious doubt our ability to determine our destiny, with present and continuing serious negative consequences for our continent.

(3) “The wilful abandonment by the G8 of its solemn commitment to implement its 2002 Africa Action Plan (G8AAP) in support of Nepad, including its failure, and ours, to ensure that the ‘new and successor’ G20 accepts at least the framework and spirit of the G8AAP. This has created a long hiatus in the development of equitable economic and other relations between Africa and the developed world, [where] the latter grouping, in its interest, has elected literally to spend time on ‘re-inventing the wheel’.”

G8 and the AU

Love or loathe him, Mbeki’s views are seriously valid and are vital reminders of how important the AU and its functions are to Africa. What he failed to say in his article, however, was that the G8’s “wilful abandonment … of the Africa Action Plan in support of Nepad” came about because he himself would not bow, in late 2003, to the G8 wishes to supplant the then nascent AU with Nepad.

To see how far the AU has come in 10 years, without the support of the G8’s Africa Action Plan, it is important to go back to the sharp exchanges between Mbeki and the G8 in 2003. In a strongly-worded reply to the then Canadian prime minister, Jean Chretien, who was fronting for the G8, Mbeki wrote on 1 November 2003 (copied to the G8, EU, the UN secretary general, the Nordic countries, members of the Nepad Implementation Committee):

“As Africans, like any other people in the world, we have the capacity to determine what is in our best interest, the determination to promote this interest to the best of our ability, and the resolve to honestly confront any tendency that is inimical to the advancement of these interests.

“The AU is the primary organisation of Africa. Nepad is its socio-economic development programme. Accordingly, Nepad is not an organisation separate from, and independent of, the AU. It has been authorised by the AU in all its elements, including the Peer Review Mechanism. There is no way in which there can be a Nepad independent of, and outside the AU in as much as there can be no socio-economic development programme covering the member countries of the European Union (EU) independent of the EU.”

Mbeki went on: “One of the dangers to us, posed by the assertion that the Nepad Peer Review process should displace all related AU legal organs, is that this seeks to encourage us to ignore decisions related to the AU, adopted by our parliaments as law. Another is that we are being encouraged to hold the AU in contempt, by treating its decisions and institutions as being inimical to ‘the logic and vision that underlie Nepad’.

“In short, we are invited to treat the AU, the parent of Nepad, as a dangerous irrelevance with regard to its Nepad offspring, whose connection with the latter may lead to the ‘unravelling’ of our external partners as you warn. As you can see, this creates what, to us, is a false dichotomy between Nepad and the AU, which seeks to oblige us to either abandon or dissolve the Union and replace it with Nepad. I am certain this is not the result you seek.”

Strong words from a passionate African! But they cut no ice with the G8, and as a result the “development partners” unravelled and wilfully abandoned their African Action Plan in support of Nepad. Thus, the great hope that Nepad held for Africa and Africans at its launch in 2001, did not, and has not, materialised at the levels expected in the AU’s first decade of existence.

Self-reliance doesn’t kill

The good side of the G8’s “willful abandonment”, though, is that, according to Nepad’s CEO, Dr Ibrahim Mayaki, “domestic revenue is now the major source of development finance in Africa, accounting for about 84% of all total sources of financing for Africa, increasing four-fold between 2002 and 2008… We are confident that increasing domestic resources for financing regional programmes will shape the continent for the better. We are committed to move Africa towards a double-digit growth, inclusive and sustainable.”

Taking it all into consideration, one can safely say the AU has made some significant and positive strides in the past decade. So much so that even the great Afro-cynic, The Economist, concurred thus in one of its editorials: “The AU is gaining weight … the lingo of Marxist liberation has gone, the talk now is of economic integration, and its pronouncements are more down-to-earth than those of its predecessor.” Some truths cannot be escaped indeed!

The optimism waltzing through Africa was made even clearer recently by Ebrahim Ismail Ebrahim, South Africa’s deputy minister of international relations, when he said: “After numerous false starts over the past decades, there is now a consensus that Africa’s time has come. What is different this time around is determined leadership, political will, and effective institutions…

“Over the past decade, Africa has made quiet progress in transforming the African Union into a powerful engine for learning, problem-solving, fostering shared values, spreading best practice, regulating behaviour, upgrading standards, monitoring government performance, and above all, energising Africa,” Ebrahim enthused.

Addressing a panel discussion on Pan-African Youth Dialogue a few weeks ago, Ebrahim talked about how the IMF and other global financial institutions had recently revealed that Africa’s GDP growth had averaged 5.5% in the years between 2000 and 2010 – more than double the rate in the 1980s and 1990s. Importantly, too, Africa’s growth acceleration has been widespread, with 27 of its 30 largest economies expanding more rapidly after 2000.

But that’s not all! Even the 2012 Africa Progress Report (APR), the respected publication by the Africa Progress Panel chaired by the former UN secretary general Kofi Annan, provides a good dose of positive news about Africa, showing how real gains have been made, and how Africa now has an unprecedented opportunity for sustained economic growth and poverty reduction.

The Panel reported: “Africa’s economies are consistently growing faster than those of almost any other region – 70% of people in Africa live in countries that have had average growth of more than 4% over the past decade. Some of the fastest-growing countries in the world are in Africa. “From 2005-2009, Ethiopia recorded higher growth than China, and Uganda outperformed India. In 2011 Ghana had the highest rate of growth in the world. GDP per capita is also rising. Growth is more diversified and revenues from natural resources accounted for no more than one third of Africa’s growth over the past decade.”

There was even more good news: “While the price boom in global commodities has contributed to Africa’s recovery,” the Panel’s report revealed, “domestic consumer markets are also growing and Africa’s private sector is an increasingly powerful force for growth. Exports are booming and export markets have become more diversified due to deepening ties with the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa). The value of Africa-BRICS trade has grown nine-fold over the past decade. And China-Africa trade volume has increased from $10bn in 2000 to $160bn in 2011.”

Other African intellectual commentators such as Prof Chris Landsberg of the University of Johannesburg, believe that the past decade has brought a renewed incarnation of Pan-Africanism. He writes: “[There has been] a clear and bold attempt to bring about the progressive transformation of the continent, economically, politically, socially and developmentally. Africans [have] articulated their own, new security regime under the banner of the concept ‘from non-interference to non-indifference’, a doctrine to face up to gross violations of human rights, genocide, unconstitutional changes of government, and instability within countries that threatened broader regional and continental stability… They set up their own Peace and Security Council to manage the new-African interventionism, which prioritises negotiations, dialogue, and the peaceful settlement of disputes, rather than the brute force that had been the modus operandi of many colonial powers.”

The challenges ahead

All this is exciting news indeed, and worth a toast as the AU celebrates its first decade of existence. However, the celebrations should not mask the challenges the AU and Africa still face. One notable challenge, and a major concern, is that of the surging population of unemployed youth in Africa. Today there are 70 million more Africans under the age of 14 than there was a decade ago, and Africa’s population is growing faster than in any other region. If the economic conditions do not improve fast enough to give jobs to the unemployed youth, the continent is sure to face trouble in the second decade of the AU’s life.

As the Africa Progress Report (APR) warned: “Even in fast-growing economies like Ghana, Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda, formal sector employment has failed to keep pace with the new entrants to the workforce. Failure to create jobs and opportunities for a rapidly growing and increasingly urbanised and educated youth population may have catastrophic consequences, socially, economically and politically.

“The Arab Spring has not gone unnoticed by Africa’s youth. While Sub-Saharan Africa does not have a vast pool of educated unemployed, and many countries have established, albeit fragile multiparty democracies, young people in Africa also care about jobs, justice and equality – and governments ignore them at their peril.”

The APR also reveals how poverty levels have fallen across Africa. However, the real success and lasting legacy of the AU will only be achieved if the current buoyancy is sustained. At the formation of the OAU in May 1963, the continent deferred work towards building some common institutions, as proposed by Ghana’s then president, Kwame Nkrumah. That not a lot of progress has been made on those common institutions nearly 50 years after they were proposed, not even in achieving visa-free travel in Africa for Africans, an anomaly highlighted by Cameron Duodu, shows how far the AU and Africa still have to go.

One of the biggest challenges is how the AU is funded. The Union has a big problem with money! Not only do member-states contribute only 40% of the AU’s budget, the non-payment of contributions by some member countries (or the annoying habit of letting contributions lapse into arrears) leaves the AU vulnerable to Western donor support and dictates. By and large, and sadly so, the AU extends its begging bowl to the West in order to survive.

How a continent of 54 countries, with the richest deposits of every natural resource in the world, can still largely rely on outside largesse to finance the activities of its continental union (even the new AU headquarters was donated by China) is a paradox that Africa will have to solve in the second decade of the AU. Having said that,  many will concur with outspoken human rights lawyer Barney Bityana when he says: “The AU still has every reason to celebrate its 10th anniversary. This is because in large measure, Africa has proved the sceptics wrong.”

Written By
New African

Previous article

Next article